Susan Yanum & Anne Schultz 5/25/11

It was interesting to note a small example of how Court Watch appears to be regarded in this building, (101 W. Congress) at least by the first person I encountered. When I had to go through Security to get into the building, the guy who checked me through noticed my yellow button, said “oh, you’re with Court Watch”, looked directly at me, smiled, and said “thank you.”

ASLYUM HEARING, JUDGE Sheila McNulty, May 25, 2011
Respondent,Cosimo ____, a Guatemalan born on 9/27/65
Hearing excerpts from Court watcher exemplifying the challenges in fulfilling the law and in receiving a positive outcome, inspite of a Judge with integrity.
The Judge asked him if he had the originals of the documents and he said no. She said – and repeated a number of times – that he must have the originals when he comes back to Court – they will be very important to his case.
He said that he didn’t know how long it would take him to get them, because they are all in Guatemala, and she said she would allow for this.
The respondent said that the police had lost his documents before.
He also said he hopes there will not be a problem in his receiving the documents when they arrive – it has happened before that he was not given documents that were sent to him. The interpreter said he didn’t know why there would have been a problem, and the Judge said that she would talk to the Guard to make sure he gets them.
She gave him a continuance til June 28th, 2011.

I was very glad that we were still in the courtroom to hear the conversation between the Judge and the translator/interpreter after the hearing because it showed the deep interest on both their parts that justice be done. I was very impressed by the general tone of courtesy, respect, and obvious real caring that was shown towards Cosimo______ by both Judge and the t/i, and pleased and relieved that the Judge had made a point of setting the continuance date at a time when she knew she would be there. As much as it could be called a pleasure to sit in on a hearing of this nature, it was a pleasure because of the integrity with which it was conducted by all concerned, certainly including the respondent. From the very beginning, when I asked through the interpreter for his permission that I be present for his case, he looked directly at me to answer yes, and his eyes were very clear. Throughout, he was articulate and obviously highly intelligent, asking his own questions, participating on his own behalf in a dignified way, always respectful and self-assured. When he got up to leave, under the armed escort of the guard, and I saw the handcuffs for the first time, I felt sick to my stomach. The orange jump suit was bad enough, but now the handcuffs.
This case was as good as it could be, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that this man should not have been here at all.


0 Responses to “Susan Yanum & Anne Schultz 5/25/11”

  1. Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

June 2011
« May    

%d bloggers like this: